Why We Chose to Homeschool

Why We Chose to Homeschool

We have only been “officially” homeschooling for a few weeks now and I can’t even begin to tell you how many times I have been asked, “Why would you want do that?” So I thought for my official first post back, after a fairly lengthy hiatus (at least for the blogging world) that answering why would be a good place to start.

There isn’t a simple answer

Honestly, the answer to that isn’t nearly as simple as those who have asked me would like it to be. They want me to give an obvious answer…there aren’t any good local schools, we don’t believe in common core, we want to be free to teach about our faith, we believe there is too much bullying in schools… the list goes on and on. In some ways these reasons are true, and yet, not really.

Confused yet? Now you know how we felt.

We are actually lucky enough to live in an area where there are many wonderful options for school. Schools filled with teachers willing to give everything they have, and more, to educate their students.  But to be fair, after being a teacher for over 15 years I know that the demands placed on teachers- by principals, parents, lawmakers, and in some cases the students themselves-make it nearly impossible for them to offer the best to every single one of their students.

Often it is the parents who complain the most, the students who are the farthest behind, or those that demand the most attention, that get it. Well, the problem with this is that my children don’t fall into any of those categories. We are blessed in that our children are (so far…) average.

They have never gotten into trouble at school. They have never required anything “extra” of their teachers and neither have we, as parents, ever had anything to complain about. While this makes for a great student in the classroom, as a parent I worry that my children’s needs will be passed over for those who are more demanding or in need of, the teacher’s immensely valuable time and talent.

Why we chose to homeschool

Having an opinion about Common Core seems to be all the rage now. People who have not had a seconds training in education, short of being a student themselves, seem to suddenly be experts on the merits or drawbacks to what merely amounts to a set of goals for learning developed mostly by legislators to align learning across the United States. Yes, I know that is a bit over simplified in explanation, but that it what it amounts to. The problem is that while there is a clear movement to common learning goals, there is a greater discrepancy now more than ever on how to attain those goals.

Some students still learn best with rote memorization, some by conceptual understanding, and others develop their own rogue ways of learning. The point is, there is a middle ground in everything and while I see the merits of Common Core as well as the drawbacks, as a parent I want the right to choose which learning works best for my children to help them become productive members of society.

I don’t want their learning to be at the whim of the “next greatest movement” in education-legislators who use buzz words for campaigns, garner support and pass their next bill.

My husband and I were both blessed with sound, faith-filled, Catholic educations. As parents, that is what we also wish for our children. We want them to learn about the love of God, the power of faith, and that there really is right and wrong in the world. The problem with this for us, like many families, is that Catholic education is expensive-especially if you have multiple children in school.

Just do the math

Once upon a time, the children of teachers could go to school where their parent taught, in many cases tuition free or deeply discounted. It was one of the perks meant to draw quality teachers to Catholic schools, despite the nearly$10,000 difference in pay from public school teachers. Now, that is not the case and the pay for Catholic school teachers has never risen to match that of public schools. So, if you wanted to bring your own children with you to school, you will pay, on the average, over $5,000 a year per child. Couple that with less pay than my public school counterparts, it makes bringing your children to school with you a significant financial hardship.

Once my husband and I did the math, after putting all of our children into school and paying the extra expenses, I would work full time, educating nearly 125 students a year,  to make a scant several hundred dollars a month and have someone else teach my children.  We just couldn’t justify that. Being free to practice our faith daily coupled with the expense of private schools were major factors in our decision.

Will we homeschool forever?

I often get asked if I’m going to do this for the next 12 years. Actually, I’m really surprised how often I’ve gotten this question. If there is one thing being a mom has taught me it’s to be flexible. Do what works for as long as it works. I have no idea how long we will homeschool or if it will be the right choice for all my kiddos.

But for now, it has been a wonderful choice for my family and I feel blessed every single day that I get to watch my children continue to grow, learn, and develop. To be fair, this really is just the tip of the iceberg in our decision make process and doesn’t even being to touch on all the thought we put into this decision, but it is a great place to start. More on that later, I promise.

Here are some pics from our very first official homeschool day

More coming on curriculum choices, routines, and survival of the fittest.

See ya next Sunday,



Find me on: Web


  1. -j
    September 14, 2016 / 10:28 pm

    I’d have to add that I feel that our decision is best for us, but isn’t necessarily what’s best for everyone. Even though a parent’s heart may be in the right place not everyone is cut out to educate their children. One of the only reasons I fully supported this in the beginning was the countless hours of research, planning, and prayer. It’s not just, hey, I’ll buy a packet of books and do this. You’re amazing and it’s takes someone amazing to add such another huge task to an already full plate. I think I was easily on board because it was you who I’d be going on this journey with.

  2. September 15, 2016 / 4:52 am

    Having run activity hour each week here on the farm for a few years I can see the benefit of homeschooling. If I had the patience with my own I’d love to have done it, with the boys especially at a young age they would have learned so much faster through practical activities here on the farm rather than classroom work. Good luck to you in your venture and I’m sure your children will thrive from your knowledge. #bestandworst

  3. Leah Miller
    September 15, 2016 / 5:23 am

    It sounds to me like you have made absolutely the right choice, for your family and yourselves, and you shouldn’t need to justify your family decisions to anyone. You are a teacher, so you are in the perfect position to teach your kids, but also you cherish their time and love to see them achieve. I think this will be a wonderful time for you. So many parents at the primary school my children attend(ed) basically see school as a day long babysitting service, with the teachers as the hired help. They are not interested in what they do, or learn, so long as someone watches them for 6 hours a day. And yet they are the first to complain if there child gets mistreated or slips behind. If I had the time, and of course an ounce of the knowledge, this is something that I would seriously consider, because my children are like yours – no burden – and therefore left to their own devices. To the extent that my son who is now at secondary school had so much catching up to do for his year 6 tests that he almost broke down. They had let him slip through the net, and it broke my heart to have to be on his back to catch up when it should never have got to that stage in the first place.

    I wish you all the best with this, I know it will be the making of you and your amazing tiny humans xxx

  4. October 11, 2016 / 2:51 pm

    Enjoy your kids and enjoy homeschool for as long as it suits your family’s needs. You owe no one an explanation or an apology. Their yours! Trust your instincts. Beautiful children.

  5. October 12, 2016 / 4:47 pm

    Good luck, I know homeschooling is popular with some adoptive parents when the school system fails them. I do hope it works out for you all. #twinklytuesday

  6. October 18, 2016 / 7:08 am

    Awe, I love reading about people’s “why” in education. The reasons are so diverse. We also homeschool and I wish you much luck and encouragement as you move forward with this new lifestyle.

Leave a Reply

Latest Posts on How to Keep Your Life From Falling Spectacularly Apart

%d bloggers like this: